September Market Report: The Fed Speaks, and Why Now’s Still Good for Buyers

The Fed finally made its widely anticipated announcement, cutting interest rates by half a point — more than many were expecting. But as has been noted, it was really always more about the anticipation of that cut. We can, for now, fairly safely expect minor mortgage rate fluctuations, but not big drops.

“For those who are ready to buy now, waiting for larger declines in mortgage rates carries some risk,” says Zillow Senior Economist Orphe Divounguy. “Absent an unexpected deterioration in the labor market, it’s unlikely mortgage rates would decline all that much more.”

But as markets continue to work their way toward some new normalcy, opportunities keep opening at non-traditional times. Rates are hovering lower than they have in 18 months, inventory is slowly reforming, and now there are more homes on the market than there have been since September 2020.

Lower Rates Are Here, but They’re Not Guaranteed to Stay

Mortgage rates and rising inventory are the two main reasons your buyer clients have a window of opportunity at this unusual time in the year. Rates, which began falling from their most recent peak in late May, have improved affordability significantly, and competition among buyers could extend into the fall.

“Mortgage rates have fallen to reflect the market’s expectations,” says Zillow Senior Economist Orphe Divounguy, “But we may even see a pull back up soon.” 

As a result, more home prices now meet an affordability threshold nationally — that means monthly payments generally take less than one-third of median household income (assuming a buyer puts 20% down, and before taxes and insurance are accounted for). The monthly payment on a typical U.S. home purchase has fallen by more than $100 since that last peak in May. For reference, the drop calculates to more than $300 a month for the average home in the expensive San Francisco metro area. 

Your Buyer Clients Have More Choices and Bargaining Power

Beyond lower costs, a number of metrics are moving in buyers’ favor. The Zillow Market Heat Index shifted from being in favor of sellers into neutral territory in July. For the past two years, sellers held their edge nationally until October. 

Homes are taking longer to sell than in recent history, but shorter than in pre-pandemic times. Homes that sold in August took 20 days to go pending, two more than in July, but about six days faster than at this time of year before the pandemic. And while inventory growth has slowed, nearly 1.18 million homes are on the market, more than any month since September 2020. 

Mortgage Payments Are Down, Rents Are Up

After a surge during the last few years, rent growth has returned to the pre-pandemic norms of 4-5%. Rent for a single family rental is up 4.5% year over year, while the typical mortgage payment for a home in the for-sale market is down 2.9% year over year.

“The gap between buying and renting has decreased,” says Divounguy. “So if you’ve been on the fence, the math starts to make a little bit more sense.”

Home Values Decline Nationally

The typical US home in August was $362,143. The typical monthly mortgage payment, assuming 20% down, was $1,827. Lower mortgage rates pushed monthly mortgage costs down 3.4% from July to August. 

  • Home values climbed month-over-month in 9 of the 50 largest metro areas in August. Gains were biggest in Buffalo (0.7%), New York (0.6%), Providence (0.4%), Hartford (0.3%), and Philadelphia (0.3%).
  • Home values fell, on a monthly basis, in 37 major metro areas. The largest monthly drops were in San Francisco (-1.3%), San Jose (-1.1%), Austin (-1%), Denver (-0.7%), and New Orleans (-0.6%).
  • Home values are up from year-ago levels in 44 of the 50 largest metro areas. Annual price gains are highest in San Jose (9.1%), Hartford (8%), Providence (7.1%), New York (7%), and San Diego (6.2%).
  • Home values are down from year-ago levels in 5 major metro areas. The largest drops were in New Orleans (-4.6%), Austin (-4.6%), San Antonio (-2.9%), Birmingham (-0.9%), and Dallas (-0.4%).
  • The typical mortgage payment is down 2.9% from last year and has increased by 103.8% since pre-pandemic.

For Sale Listings Up More Than 22% Yoy

  • New listings decreased by 1.1% month-over-month in August.
  • New listings increased by 0.8% this month compared to last year.
  • New listings are 21.3% lower than pre-pandemic levels.
  • For-sale inventory (the number of listings active at any time during the month) in August increased by 0.2% from last month.
  • There were 22.1% more for-sale listings active in August compared to last year.
  • Inventory levels are -30.8% lower than pre-pandemic levels for the month.

More Than 25% of August Listings Saw a Price Cut

25.9% of listings in August had a price cut, compared to 26.2% in July and 23.4% in August 2023.

  • 33.4% of homes sold above their list price last month. That’s compared to 35.4% in June and 39.1% in July of 2023. 

Newly Pending Sales Down

  • Newly pending listings decreased by 5% in August from the prior month.
  • Newly pending listings decreased by 2.9% from last year.
  • Median days to pending, the typical time since initial list date for homes that went under contract in a month, is at 20 days in August, up 2 days since last month.
  • Median days to pending increased by 7 days from last year.

Check the Market Heat Index for Your Area

  • Zillow’s market heat index shows the nation is currently a neutral market.
  • The strongest seller’s markets in the country are Buffalo, Hartford, San Jose, Boston, and New York.
  • The strongest buyer’s markets in the country are New Orleans, Miami, Jacksonville, Austin, and Tampa.

Rent Growth Continues to Cool

  • Asking rents increased by 0.2% month-over-month in August. The pre-pandemic average for this time of year is 0.4%.
  • Rents are now up 3.4% from last year.
  • Rents fell, on a monthly basis, in 2 major metro areas – Austin (-0.4%) and Boston (-0.1%).
  • Rents are up from year-ago levels in 49 of the 50 largest metro areas. Annual rent increases are highest in Hartford (7.7%), Cleveland (7.2%), Louisville (7.1%), Richmond (6.8%), and Virginia Beach (6.6%).

Statistics courtesy Zillow Research.

Work With Ben

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.